Older Key West Charlottesville homes for sale in the 140-acre Key West neighborhood located off scenic Route 20 in Albemarle County.

These homes for sale in Key West Charlottesville VA offer privacy with generous, .5 to 6-acre lots surrounded by mature trees, private cul-de-sacs, and swimming, tennis, and social activities (for those who want it).

Click Here to View Key West Charlottesville Homes for Sale

Key West Charlottesville is made up of 99 homes of mostly 3-4 bedrooms and built in the 1960s-1970s.

Architectural styles range from colonial, to contemporary, ramblers to ranches, and 1-2 story split levels (similar to That 70s Show!). 

There were only 3 homes for sale in Key West Charlottesville VA in 2022.

The highest price paid was $530,000. The lowest price paid was $465,000, and the median price was $506,000.

But don’t let that $506,000 price fool you.

11 homes have sold since 2021 and the highest price paid was $815,000, the low was $455,000, and the median was $510,000.

Therefore, I can say the median price for a home in the Key West Subdivision Charlottesville VA is $510,000 in 2022.

Click Here to View the Last 11 Homes Sold in Key West Charlottesville

The last home built in Key West Charlottesville was in 2020 at 107 Bollingbrook Drive.

The 44-acre Key West Club is the Key West neighborhood club that offers tennis, swimming, and social events to both adults and kids.

Note – You do NOT need to join the club if you live here.

The club’s swimming facilities include a 25-yard Junior Olympic-size pool with a diving board. There is also a kiddie pool.

Restrooms, a snack bar, ping pong, and picnic tables are available at the covered facility.

Both private and group swimming classes are offered. And their swim team, the Key West Killer Whales, competes in the Jefferson Swim League which includes Farmington, Glenmore, Ednam, Forest Lakes, and others.

There are two asphalt tennis courts that are used all year long plus a youth tennis program that competes in local league matches similar to the swim team.

Participants in our young tennis program compete in local league matches.

A local pro offers tennis lessons to both adults and kids.

The Key West Club Member fees are as follows: $165 per swimmer for the first two children in a family and $100 for each child thereafter.

For non-members, the fee is $195 for the first two children and $115 for each child thereafter.

The original Key West House was built in 1852 and sits on 5 acres. It is located at 405 Key West Drive. It sold in 2017 for $925,000.

Another historic home in the Key West Charlottesville is Burnley Tavern, circa 1740, which was moved to the Key West neighborhood Charlottesville in 1938.

There is some great Virginia history here.

After those two historic homes were built, nothing was built until 1960 when the Key West subdivision Charlottesville VA became a reality.

Key West Charlottesville HOA Fees. $0!!!! There are no HOA or setup/transfer fees. 

Click Here to View a Video of Future Key West Charlottesville Homes For Sale

Albemarle County Public Schools serve the Key West subdivision Charlottesville Va with Stony Point Elementary, Burnley Middle, and Monticello High.

Location: From US-250 E turn left onto VA-20N/Stony Point Rd, left onto Key West Drive. 5 minutes from Pantops, Pen Park, & Darden Towe Park.

My thoughts…As you will notice Key West Charlottesville homes for sale are older. In fact, only 4 homes were built after 2000.

I like the location so this is a great opportunity to pick up an older home and renovate it.

But beware, Rt 20 is a very windy road and tough to negotiate at night.

Another problem is Monticello High School being so far away. To and from high school would be an hour each way. Can your kids handle this?

Thanks for reading along,

I would be thrilled to be your Charlottesville realtor.

Toby Beavers – Charlottesville realtor since 2003

Call or text me at 434-327-2999